Earlier today I sent the following press release to the local newspaper. They do not normally print me so I thought that I might post it here so that you can read it in full.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consultation fever has gripped the Borough with no less than three on the go at the same time. The proposed new Academy and school closures in Stockingford, the Borough council response to the Regional Spatial Strategy and the Fire Service review. I do wonder how many of these consultations are merely box ticking exercises for a government protocol.
With regards to the closure of the two schools in Stockingford and construction of the resultant academy I have considerable reservations. I have been a permanent fixture at the public meetings held at Alderman Smith school and have witnessed the same tired reasons paraded remorselessly. Despite the protestations of governors, staff, parents and pupils no alternatives have been brought forward to settle the protesters concerns.
Manor Park and Alderman Smith schools have over the past three years shown consistent and considerable improvement which is entirely down to the dedication and hard work of the governors and staff who were in place at the time. It would have been nice to see this continue rather than forcibly replacing the elected governing body with an unelected one appointed by the County Council and over which the parents will have no control at all.
The information came out at the public meeting on 7th October at Alderman Smoth school that across the county of Warwickshire there are more than the accepted number of available school places. Closing a school in Nuneaton will bring this number back within 'acceptable' parameters. Nuneaton takes the pain and the remainder of the county breaths easily.
No notice has been taken of effect that the Regional Spatial Strategy will have on demographics which, though currently in consultation stage the Borough Council has been left in no doubt as to the fact that the provision is compulsory and we only get to decide where and not how many homes will be forced into the borough. I am sure that you get the theme here. These forced additional homes will not just affect us with our own increase of more than 10,000 new homes but including the 'overspill' from Coventry the number may be as high as 15,000. I cannot believe that these homes will not contain any children. This massive increase in the size of the borough has not however been taken into consideration in the school figures.
Marion Plant, head of the North Warwickshire College is to be congratulated for leading her team to their 'Outstanding' rating by the OFSTED inspectors. This is really difficult to achieve and just as hard to maintain because you have to show improvement to maintain it. They also have input into educational provision at every school in the borough and are the main educational partner for George Elliot school. Marion and her team are the only potential educational sponsor for the academy and have insisted repeatedly that they did not come forward and bid for it. They were asked to take it because no-one else came forward. It is my belief that the team of Governors and managers will be spread too thin on the ground to do the job as effectively as they would like and therefore should not be taking the project forward at all.
In response to my statement above at the recent public meeting Mrs Plant gave out the information that arrangements and people had already been put in place at the college in preparation for the academy. A head teacher has already been engaged as well. This all seems to me to be too much happening while the process is in its 'consultation phase'. The County Council is pushing too hard on this and has of course offered no option to turn the proposals down. Exactly how many signatures/letters does it take. I will come back to that.
Information was released by Ed Balls, Schools Secretary, on 22nd september that 30% of existing academies fail to meet the requirement of 30%+ pupils achieving 5 A* to C grades in GCSE's. Both of the schools that it is proposed to close are already above that target with a markedly upward trend. Bear in mind that at the Conservative party conference Shadow Schools Secretary Michael Gove said that with days of a Conservative government, "all state schools would be able to opt for Academy status and free themselves from local authority control."
The Fire Service consultation scares me. This time the County Council are proposing to close seven fire stations all together and leave us 100 firefighters short of the number that we already have. How often do you read in this paper that fire crews have had to dash off to a fire in another area and that our towns were subsequently covered by Atherstone? Not any more if they get their way!
There are some terrific facts in the consultation document such as that 43% of retained fire engines may not be available currently due to insufficient crewing. So by his own evidence we need more crews not less! A recently revealed risk assessment has shown that their own figures do not add up for public safety. The wording of the consultation is clearly designed to elicit agreement and is then followed on with a touchy feely question about how that makes you feel. Aah bless. This ticks more beaurocratic boxes than I can count but it does not provide you with an effective means of turning over the 'proposal' to leave you with vastly reduced fire cover.
It is not sufficient anymore apparently just to disagree with a consultation. You are now expected to suggest an alternative. Time for us all to get trained as a Chief Fire Officer then maybe? Do not forget the crystal ball training. Figures are necessarily based upon the past. This proposal knows what will happen tomorrow. I also notice that your responses must be sent to Warwickshire Fire and Rescue Service. Great, apart from the fact that they are not going to make any decisions on the matter. Your recently elected County Councillors will do that.
I have had a better idea. Why do we not get our elected councillors from Borough and County level to contact every single one of Warwickshire County Council's controlling Conservative group and argue with/encourage them directly to make them understand that being sure that we are safe in our beds at night is by definition far more important to us than some of the other projects that the county council spends money on within the community. If they do not believe us all that they have to do is provide a long list of projects that they fund and we will put them in our order of priority. I am not a betting man but I think that Fire and Rescue would be at or near the top.
Much has been made of Councillors collecting signatures in the town centres on all of these consultations both in the local newspapers and on social networking sites. I have seen it said that this is not political. Rubbish! The Labour party brought in and continues to support the expansion of the academy scheme and the Conservative party has pledged to expand it even quicker. Across the country reviews of services have taken place that have been just as unpopular as this one. The councillors from these two parties represent parties who agree completely on most things these days and therefore can neither disagree politically nor make too much noise for fear of the wrath of head office. The campaigning that you have seen has all been self publicity to make themselves appear hard working and concerned. This has been done by politicians who want to be seen by the public to be campaigning on their behalf. Campaigning both in the local newspapers and on social networking websites only helps their personal political profile, not the issue.
The time that has been spent leafleting and collecting signatures by councillors on both issues would have utilised much more effectively if they had instead spent it trying to contact and apply pressure to the Conservative County Councillors from the whole of Warwickshire for support to overturn these proposals. That is the only effective method of changing things, behind the scenes! This is what elected representatives are for.
What happens to a petition? Massive publicity for the party that does the campaign, a chance for everyone in politics to gain exposure on the issues and clap each other on the backs for achieving cross partry agreement. So great benefits for the public profile of the politicians but what actually happens to the petition once it has been handed in infront of a photographer of course on the council steps? Not a lot. Fact, petitions are not a part of the decision making process!
Councillors make up their own minds as to what they think is best on any issue. This is what they are elected for. Then they listen to the opinion of the officers of the council very closely. County Council officer Mark Gore stood at the front of the public meeting and stated that in the face of what the speakers had said he, "remained un-convinced. I am convinced that a school needs to close." These are the words of the county council officer who will be advising the Conservative cabinet of Warwickshire County Council who have a massive majority of seats and is controlled largely be councillors from the south. In this borough we have plenty of experience of the ramifications of that position. They then look at the politics of the situation and make their decision. Having recently won an overwhelming majority they are not worried. Petitions allow campaigning politicians to look good in public before the petition, and sometimes the politicians themselves, gather dust prior to disposal. petitions form no part of the decision making process unless the issue is massive and only then if there is an election pending.
In case you have not noticed these issues are being pushed just after the elections but as soon as possible after so as not to adversely effect the general election campaigns.
Borough Council leader Peter Gilbert this week had a full page spread in the Nuneaton News asking people to give three minutes to sign a petition and tell others. Great campaigning for him but ineffective for the issue and he knows it. I do hope that the taxpayer did not pay for that political advertising. I will leave you by asking you to spend three minutes doing something useful. E-mail all of your local councillors at Borough and County level TELLING THEM to campaign directly to the controlling group on your behalf. This is their job after all. You might as well get some use out of them.
Cllr Martyn Findley.
British National Party.